1. Athletic Ability
#1 Criteria for college coaches. You have to have some game. We teach you how to showcase your abilities.
2. Academics - GPA and Test Scores
Most offers will be a combination of academic and athletic money. The higher your academics are = more academic money you receive.
3. Your desire to attend their school
College coaches want to know you are serious about attending their school and playing for them.
College coaches want good locker room and dugout players. They don't want to babysit players and/or have high maintenance athletes.
Get it done on the field/court and in classroom, be a great teammate and "coachable" player, and attack your recruiting like you attack your sport.